• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Putnam Independent Living Services

  • Home
  • Current Calendar
  • Programs
    • Independent Living Services
      • Deaf Services
      • Independent Living Skills
      • Peer Advisement
      • Information and Referral
      • Benefits and Entitlements Advisement
      • Trainings & Workshops
    • Specialized Programs
      • Olmstead Housing Subsidy Program
      • NY Connects, No Wrong Door
      • Nursing Home Transition and Diversion
      • Traumatic Brain Injury Regional Resource Development Center
      • Open Doors Transition Center
      • Prevent Type 2 Diabetes
    • Advocacy
      • Parent Training and Information Center (PTIC)
      • Mental Health Peer Advocacy
      • Equal Access and the Americans with Disabilities Act
      • Educational Advocacy
    • Peer Integration Program
  • About Us
    • Westchester Independent Living Center Annual Reports
    • PILS
    • Main Office
    • Board of Directors
    • PILS Department Managers
    • Grievance Procedure
    • Press Room
  • Get Help & Services
    • Employment Opportunities
    • Get Help & Services
    • Contact Us
    • Housing
    • Transportation
    • Benefits
    • Education
    • Employment
    • Healthcare
    • Your Rights
  • Donate
  • Independent Living
    Information, Referral, Training and Peer Support
  • Specialized Programs
    Community Living Support, Transition and Diversion
  • Advocacy
    Education, Community Access and Equality
  • Peer Integration Program
    Removing Barriers to Employment

Voter Inclusion

Mr. Philip Zegarelli
Village Manager
Village of Briarcliff Manor
1111 Pleasantville Road
Briarcliff Manor, NY 10510

April 26, 2014

Re: New Voting Machines

Dear Mr. Zegarelli:

As an advocate for persons with disabilities and as a voter with a disability, I am deeply troubled by your aggressive opposition to the recent implementation of the HAVA Ballot Marking Device (BMD) voting machines throughout polling places in Westchester County. Your aggrieved letter to County Executive Robert Astorin o hold the BMDs accountable for “infringing on the constitutional right to vote and to privacy.” In addition, you provided a list of fourteen complaints and observations in your letter to justify your position, which I have addressed in this correspondence.

I would like to vigorously correct you in your assertion that th e new BMD machines proved to be a “failure” during the past state-wide election The BMDs were not responsible for intimidating and frustrating voters and compromising their privacy; the lack of adequate poll worker training disenfranchised these voters. As its name implies, the Ballot Marking Device does just that: it marks the ballot for voters who are unable to manually do so. It can enlarge ballot print (see complaint #8), it can alter ballot contrast (see complaint #s 4,5) and it provides first time voters with instruction for its use (see complaint #11). It seems that poll workers were remiss in informing voters with visual and neurological conditions about these features. If poll workers were trained properly and exercised the required oversight of poll site operations, more than enough privacy stands would have been available to voters as well as privacy sleeves (see complaint #s 1,3,9); election inspectors would have known how to properly insert ballots into the scanners or instruct voters how to do so, ensuring their privacy (see complaint #s 10, 12); and the proper pens – not Magic Markers -would have been placed inside the privacy booths for voters to mark their ballots (see complaint #6). The BMD is also engineered to display the marked ballot to voters for final review. If there was a mistake, the ballot will be marked spoiled and a new one (up to three) would be issued to the voter (see complaint #13).

You closed your letter by stating that the “old” system worked well and “if it isn’t broken, don’t fix it. ”The “old” lever machines do not work well for voters with varying types of visual, mobility and cognitive disabilities. Voters with visual disabilities are not able to read the ballot; voters with limited mobility capacity are not able to reach and/or operate the levers; voters with certain cognitive limitations are not able to visually focus on the current ballot style associated with the old system.

New York voters with disabilities rallied for their right to gain access to Ostego County’s inaccessible polling sites in 1999, which resulted in a lawsuit filed by the state Attorney General’s office against the county. In 2004, disability rights advocates and several plaintiffs filed a lawsuit in federal court against the Westchester County Board of Elections for polling site access violations under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Hundreds of disability rights advocates, as well as advocacy organizations across the state, have worked consistently and conscientiously since HAVA was introduced in 2002 to partner with the New York State Board of Elections in mapping out voting machine accessibility standards for voters with disabilities. Section 301(a)(3)(A) of HAVA requires that voting systems “be accessible for individuals with disabilities . . . in a manner that provides the same opportunity for access and participation (including privacy and independence) as for other voters.”]

The BMD machines provide this same opportunity for voters with disabilities and uphold our right to a fully inclusive voting system.

Lisa Tarricone
Director, Systems Advocacy

Cc: Timothy C. Idoni
John Nonna
William Burton
Westchester Board of Elections

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Primary Sidebar

Get Help & Services

First Step to Services

Calendar

Trainings & Workshops

News You Can Use

Emergency Preparedness

Emergency Preparedness

March 2023 Newsletter

February 2023 Newsletter

January 2023 Newsletter

Documentar el Progreso de su Hijo

Documenting your Child’s progress during the Shutdown

ASL COVID-19 Video Series

Living with a Brain Injury during COVID

Resource Directory

HIV Resources for Individuals who are Deaf or Hard of Hearing

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

Key Resource Links

  • White Plains Housing Registry
  • Westchester Independent Living Center
  • Independent Living Centers in New York State
  • Everybody: an Artifact History of Disability in America
  • Fair Housing Amendments Act
  • The Americans with Disabilities Act
  • The Philosophy of Independent Living
  • ADA National Network
  • Helpful Links
  • Make a Donation to PILS/WILC

Shop Amazon at smile.amazon.com. Choose Westchester Independent Living Center. WILC will receive a donation!

Footer

Contact

Putnam Independent Living Services
1441 Route 22, Suite 204
(Tompkins Mahopac Bank building)
Brewster, New York 10509
845-228-7457 (Voice)
914.259.8036 (VP)
845-228-7460 (Fax)
contact@putnamils.org
Directions to PILS

 Contact

Westchester Independent Living Center
10 County Center Road 2nd floor
White Plains, NY 10607
(914) 682-3926 (Voice)
914-259-8036 (VP)
(914) 682-8518 (FAX)
Contact@wilc.org
Directions to WILC

  • Site Map

 Contact

Yonkers Outreach Office
Pathways to Success
75 Riverdale Avenue
Yonkers, New York 10701
914-376-8600

Copyright © 2023